Testimonials & Reviews

Colts Neck Inn Restaurant has received widespread attention from customers and food critics alike. We have compiled a selection of testimonials and critical reviews for you here.


  • 2010 Jersey Shore Metro Mix:  Best Steak
  • 2010 Asbury Park Press Reader's Choice:  Best Steak House
  • 2011 Jersey Shore Metro Mix:  Best Steak
  • 2011 New Jersey Monthly Magazine Reader's Choice:  Best Steak Central Jersey
  • 2012 Jersey Shore Metro Mix: Best Steak
  • 2015 APP Best of the Best, Best Steakhouse and BBest runch



Critics Reviews

Voted Best Of Metromix 2010 , 2011 & 2012: Best Steak


"Steak + House, a.k.a., two-thirds of the survival equation, i.e., the manliest compound word in the history of language. For many, that first bite of a perfect steak is the equivalent of primal restoration; like coming face to face with our ageless self -- and then eating him. The Colts Neck Inn Steak & Chop House reminds us why it's so damn sweet to be a carnivore."


" Famous as a summer stopover beach and racetrack bound travelers, Colts Neck Inn Steak & Chop House is a welcome watering hole and eatery for locals and visitors year round.  The restaurant is known for superior steaks, pork chops and seafood, as well as live music and dancing Friday and Saturday nights."


Asbury Park Press Reader's Choice 2010 Best of Monmouth County:  Steak House 


Customer Testimonials

"Colts Neck Inn Restaurant is simply a great place to eat: the food is incredible and the service is delightful. I highly recommend it!"


"Great restaurant for entertaining clients... by a landslide."


"One of the best places I have eaten, not just in Colts Neck but anywhere!"


A is for Awesome
By smileyface23, May 6, 2011

Overall rating:

Every since we saw that they won Best Steak we have been coming regularly & are never dissappointed. They consistently deliver an excellent steak, with a warm & relaxed atmosphere. Check out their wine list also, it is pretty well rounded. This is the place for a great steak & a laid back vibe.


Steak Lover's Delight
By albertolini, April 11, 2011

Overall rating:

Note to all diners: If you love steak this is Heaven! Try the 16oz Filet Mignon fit for a king & I definately recommend the Adult Mac n Cheese & Creamed Spinach. You can dine her w/ clients or family, very friendly staff. This place hands down has the Best Steak around!